• Elmira, NY Phone: 607-734-6527607-734-6527
  • Corning, NY Phone: 607-962-6831 Phone: 607-962-6831


mobile callClick to Call
Elmira Office

2205 College Ave
Elmira, NY 14903

mapGet Directions

Corning Office

39 E Pulteney St
Corning, NY 14830

mapGet Directions

Life Insurance bg Image About Stewart Agency, Inc.

Insurance rates that can make you smile

Life Insurance bg Image New York Homeowners with home insurance coverage

Insurance Matters... So Should Your Stewart Agency, Inc.

Life Insurance bg Image New York Life insurance coverage

Insurance doesn't have to be complicated, email Us with your questions

Instant Online Quote

About Stewart
Agency, Inc.

Stewart Agency, Inc. offers tailored insurance solutions.

We are your local, trusted independent insurance agency.

We consider everyone and every policy to be unique which is why you need an experienced insurance agency to help you find your insurance coverage. With our guidance, you can have peace of mind knowing what matters to you most is protected.

At Stewart Agency, Inc., we take the time to thoroughly review your insurance needs so that we can protect your assets at competitive rates, and we’re proud to say that our inclusive solutions are capable of giving you the peace of mind you’ve been searching for. Whether you are in need of personal insurance, Medicare, or business insurance, your coverage needs are our top priority.

We understand that your insurance needs are unique to you. This is why, as an independent insurance agency, we can offer you coverage tailored to you. By working with several top-rated insurance companies, we work to custom-build a policy that meets your needs at a price that is right for you. That way your peace of mind is ensured.

Meet Our Team

Insurance advisors who truly work for you.

Not all insurance agents are created equal. At Stewart Agency, Inc., we go out of our way to treat our clients like people and we use our industry experience and diversified knowledge base to protect what you value most.

Gregory Stewart

Gregory Stewart,

877-734-6527 (FAX)
Extension 3303

Michelle Ballings                                         
Client Advisor
Extension 3305
877-734-6527 (FAX)


Michelle Ballings is a licensed client advisor with the Stewart Agency, Inc. with a concentration on homeowners’ sales and service. She works toward getting you the right coverage at the most affordable price with a thorough household analysis which we call our Protection Review.

She has excelled in understanding coverage knowledge and options, and with various companies to place your coverage with, she has the opportunity and the education to tailor a policy to fit your individual needs. She starts with getting to know you on a personal level by asking questions, and with this info, she can piece together the right homeowners’ protection package. To her, a home is more than just a foundation, walls, and a roof, it is a place where memories are made and kept, it is a legacy, and to many their life’s greatest investment. She enjoys uncovering those needs and finding creative ways to meet those needs and make you feel confident in your home insurance decisions.

Michelle has been P&C licensed for 15 years, 8 of which she has been as a client advisor for the Stewart Agency, Inc. In her time outside of the office, she enjoys cooking, gardening, and shopping.

Erin Burgess

Client Advisor
877-734-6527 (FAX)
Extension 3304

Erin Burgess is a client advisor with the Stewart Agency, Inc. In this role, Erin strives to deliver the best possible customer service experience for every client. Erin makes sure that every account is handled with diligence and attention to detail. Trina treats every client like family, she builds personal relationships and takes the utmost care with each account. 

With a friendly demeanor, Erin makes you feel comfortable and welcome. With over 9 years of experience in the business, she is very knowledgeable and ready to help.


Katie Cummings

Client Advisor
877-734-6527 (FAX)
Extension 3307

Robin Massa             
     Robin Massa

Client Advisor
877-734-6527 (FAX)
Extension 3308

I am a licensed client advisor with over 22 years of overall experience in home, auto, motorcycle, RV, landlord, and excess umbrella protection. I strive to give the best client experience possible every step of the way from purchasing your first home to enjoying your seasonal toys.

I provide excellent, timely customer service with an articulate attention to detail, making sure all your questions are answered while advising the best protection for you and your lifestyle. It is important to me that you feel confident with your coverage selections knowing that you are protected from the unexpected and have a full understanding of your policies.


Julia Reilly

Client Advisor
877-734-6527 (FAX)
Extension 3306